I’ve always worried about Charlie. From the very first day we met, she’s always had assorted quirks and oddities. But she was easily the most affectionate and loving dog I’ve ever come across, and I like to think that she knew we saved her life.

You see, Charlie was part of an unplanned and unwanted litter of pups. My dear friend, Heather, had an uncle-in-law who lived on a farm with a bunch of loose dogs running around. Unfortunately, he was a mean, miserable son-of-a-beach, and never had his female dog fixed. Surprise, surprise, she was the neighborhood tramp; and every time she bore a litter of pups, he would let her nurse them and bond with them; then throw them in a burlap bag and drown them in the nearby river.
That is, until SUPER HEATHER heard about his evil machinations! She and her husband drove to his farm in the middle of the night, and puppynapped Charlie and her brothers and sisters. They were so tiny – still needing to be bottle fed – and were deathly terrified of people. But SUPER HEATHER was conveniently unemployed at the time, and was able to act as a surrogate mama to those five puppies.

As soon as I heard what she had done, I offered to help however I could. I brought over puppy food and toys and blankets, and stopped every night after work to help change the kennel newspaper and take the puppies out for potty breaks. After a few days, I noticed one of the puppies took a liking to me. As soon as I walked through the door at SUPER HEATHER’s house and she heard my voice, she would cry and carry on and bark with all her squeaky puppy might.

And that was all it took. I was in love.

I brought Charlie home to my modest little 2-bedroom ranch in the suburbs, where she proceeded to pee on every available surface while trying to blame poor Maggie for her indiscretions. Oh, those early days were trying.

And not only was Charlie hostile to Maggie, she about drove my neighbors crazy with her daily separation anxiety. Turns out she bonded with us a little too well, and would spend her days crying out for someone, anyone, to come and release her from the confines of her kennel.

But time wore on, as time will do, and we all managed to co-exist peacefully. Maggie learned to stop snarling at her antagonistic little sister, and Charlie learned to BACK THE F*CK OFF before Maggie ripped her darling little head off.
But then September 11th hit, and we all realized the frailty and delicate nature of life. I had been living in a sea of denial (because it ain’t just a river in Egypt), and desperately wanted to find the love of my life. Or at least someone willing to put up with my myriad of crap.
But the internet dating thing, it just didn’t work out. I met losers and psychos and weirdos (oh my!), all the while preferring to spend my evenings with a pizza, a good book, and my faithful furry companions.
Until I met Dave. Every day, we spent time getting to know one another; either by phone calls or e-mails or quick dinner dates after work. Things were progressing really quickly, and one Friday night, I decided to make him my world-famous grilled salmon. No man can resist the grilled salmon.
Now, Dave was a good guy. Upon entering my house, he even took off his shoes so as not to track dirt all over the floor. After dinner, things heated up & we moved to my boudoir for a little round of hanky panky. After the dirty dancing was finished and the sheets had cooled, he gathered up his things for the drive back to his apartment. Except for one little problem.
Charlie had destroyed his shoes. There was nothing left except two regurgitated shoelaces and a half-eaten sole.

I did the only thing I could do. Let him spend the night, and took him shoe shopping the next morning. And the rest, as they say, is history. He asked me to marry him, we ran away to Saint Lucia to get married, and moved into a brand new house just off the river.
Things were good between Charlie & Maggie, but Maggie’s hips kept getting worse and worse. When Dave’s wretched mother came over at Christmas, we knew it would be our last holiday together. And how did Charlie take the news? She growled at my mother-in-law at every given opportunity. When Rosemarie tried to put food in Charlie’s kennel, Charlie growled at her. When Rosemarie went upstairs to bed, Charlie would follow her and grumble. I didn’t make a big issue of it – figured Charlie was just stressed out with the move and the extra houseguest – and let it go. Secretly, I praised her for being such a great judge of character and snuck in extra kisses and milk bones.
About four or five months later, I came home from work to find Charlie’s kennel empty and no sign of Maggie. Assuming the worst, my heart started pounding and I found myself bawling as I went up the stairs. I kept calling out for them, but neither one barked so much as a happy hello to me. When I got to the top of the stairs, I turned into our bedroom, expecting to find Maggie had passed away with Charlie staying close to her dearly departed sister.
Then, I heard it. “Thumpa thumpa thumpa thumpa thumpa.” It was Maggie’s tail, wagging under the covers where she had crawled to hide. And still, no sign of Charlie. Until I glanced out the window and saw a streak of white, cowering in the back corner of our fenced in yard. Turns out, Charlie saw a bunny through our sliding glass patio door, and charged the kennel and the patio doors until she was able to get into the yard. According to our neighbors, the bunny narrowly escaped and Charlie spent the entire afternoon hiding behind the one and only tree in our backyard.

About a month after the bunny incident, we made the decision to have Maggie put down. She could barely walk, struggling to climb the stairs to go to bed with us. If she did manage to make it to the top, she’d often vomit from the pain. It was just too much.
Putting her down was so hard, but we only allowed ourselves to grieve for a few hours. That afternoon, we’d made arrangements to welcome Zoey into our home. We knew Charlie needed another sister to keep her company, and picked up Zoey at the nearby humane society.

Charlie was used to being the center of our world, and it took her a few months to be fully accepting of Zoey. Soon enough, they were going outside together, lounging on the deck together, and sharing their toys with each other. And getting into trouble together.

That picture was snapped after the two of them tag-teamed a poor little birdie to it’s unfortunate demise. Then took turns rolling on the carcass until the two of them were good and stinky, after which they proudly kerplopped the remains on the sill of the patio door.
It was about this time that I quit working, and spent all my time obsessing over getting pregnant. Charlie & Zoey were so happy to have me home with them during the day, and we fell into an easy routine of lazy mornings, lunches on the patio, and road trips in the afternoon.

Charlie was as affectionate as ever, jumping on the bed & giving me puppy kisses before I was fully awake each morning. But underneath all that love and squishy puppy nose, she was struggling with The Dark Side.

We had to keep her food dish separate from Zoey’s, or she’d growl when they stood side-by-side to eat.

And she’d panic and hide whenever we sneezed or coughed or hung up laundry (something about the snapping of the clothes sent terror through her veins). But we’d always redirect her anger or offer up some reassurance and extra love.

She was always happy to be by my side. Even when I was crying every day, and mad at the world because I couldn’t get pregnant. She never questioned why she wasn’t enough, why I *needed* to have a baby, why I was always so sad. She loved me, no matter how awful I was.

And then we moved again. But she took it all in stride.

More or less.

And then I got pregnant. And she still stuck by my side. Happy to see me so happy, and sensing the little life that was growing inside of me. She’d often lay her head on my lap, with her ear resting softly against my belly.

She loved my being pregnant, because it meant less time away from her and many more hours of bed rest.

And then the baby came, along with strange smells, sleepless nights, and so much crying. Oh God, the crying. I know it scared her, to hear those desperate screams coming from such a small body. But she tried to adjust, and learned to love her new baby brother.

Until he got mobile. Sadly, something in her drastically changed when he started crawling around. She became extremely skittish around him, growling if he got too close to her food dish or her toys. We tried to redirect her or distract him, but the problems were escalating. It was like she was unintentionally seeing him as a rabbit or some other small animal. As an item of prey. But she tried to get control of it, and seemed fine when all of us were outside together.

She would swim in her kiddie swimming pool or play with her toys or chase the birdies. I never felt threatened by her when we were outside.

Then, over Memorial Day weekend, she nipped Mason. My sister-in-law and niece were visiting, and I thought the extra stress & noise were too much for her fragile little psyche. I didn’t make a big deal out of it at the time; but looking back, that was the beginning of the end.

If we put him in the walker, she would walk behind him and growl; going so far as to push the base of it with her teeth. Every time he came near her, she would jump up and try and get away from him as fast as she could. You could literally see her battling her inner demons. Deep down, she knew he wasn’t going to hurt her. But she knew she couldn’t control her evil impulses.

And last Wednesday, she snapped at him. I had just hung up the phone in our bedroom, and Mason snuck out the door ahead of me. I heard a low, rumbling, horrifying growl, followed by the unmistakable sound of Charlie’s teeth angrily clamping down.
I was terrified. I fully expected to see blood pouring out of my son; but fortunately, he was able to move out of the way before she bit him. I yelled at her and tried to give her a slap on the mouth, but she hung her head down and ran off before I could get to her. From that moment on, I knew she couldn’t be trusted.
I spent Thursday and Friday with my guard up, scared to let Mason come anywhere near her without my constant supervision. And it was exhausting. I love Mason (and Charlie, too), but it was impossible to spend every second watching him. Our kitchen has a small island/counter extension, and I was too scared to let him be on one side of it (where the dogs’ food dishes are) and me on the other.
And on Sunday morning, disaster struck. We gathered in Mason’s bedroom for a Father’s Day cuddle; and Dave and I sat on the floor to let Mason have a little crawl around. Charlie came into the bedroom to see what was going on, and kerplopped herself down between me and Dave. When Mason came crawling back into the bedroom, she let out the same low growl I had heard on Wednesday and curled her lip at him, baring all her teeth. If Dave or I hadn’t been on the floor with her and scooped up Mason, she would have bit him.
So, we made the agonizing decision to have her put down. I knew she couldn’t be given to anyone else. She was a ticking time bomb, and it was only a matter of time until she attacked. I honestly don’t think she would have meant to hurt Mason. She just couldn’t control herself.
We spent Sunday together, repeatedly filling up her pool with clean water so she could swim and splash and enjoy the day. And Sunday night, we made her a big plate of scrambled eggs for dinner. I expected to have Monday with her, and wanted to make the appointment for the last one of the day. I figured the vet’s office would be quiet, and I could spend a few last quiet hours with her.
Monday morning, I called our vet; and found out the only time they had open was for 10:15, so I booked it and called Dave to come home. We got my parents to come and watch Mason and Zoey, and tearfully loaded Charlie into the car for her final ride with us.
I cried the whole way to the vet’s office. I knew she was aggressive and had to be put down before she hurt Mason or one of us. I knew it in my head, but my heart couldn’t (and still doesn’t) understand. We filed into the clinic, and settled down on the blanket we brought along for her to rest on.
The vet came in, and gave her a sedative shot to calm her down. But she fought it, and she fought it hard. She leaned against me like she did when I was pregnant, letting me put my arms around her to rub her belly and snuggle into her sweet, soft neck. After 10 minutes, she laid down on the blanket; but stayed coherent enough to raise her head when the bell rang in the office or when her name was called. We cried and cried and cried. She just wasn’t ready to let go yet.
After 20 minutes, the vet came in and gave her another shot of sedative. It took about 5 minutes, but she finally laid her head down on the blanket as her breathing became soft and shallow. We stayed with her, gently petting her side and encouraging her to rest. We repeatedly told her what a good dog she was, and how much we loved her. I told her that she was my favorite, that she would always be my favorite; but it was time for her to go and find Maggie on the other side of the bridge. I whispered that we would meet again someday, and that I would never stop loving her. And I kept telling her how sorry I was.
And with that, she slipped away. I sobbed and told her one last time that I was sorry. Sorry she wasn’t enough. Sorry I let her love me through all the dark days, only to throw her away when my dreams finally came true.

Everyone keeps telling us we did the right thing, but I still have a hard time believing it. And in my heart, I’m relieved we had her put down before she hurt Mason. This way, I choose to remember the wonderful memories of her and all the good times we shared. Had she bitten Mason, I would be filled with hatred and spite; and that’s not how I want to remember my Baby Bean.
We’re all lost without her, unsure of what to do with ourselves. I emptied her swimming pool, put away her dog dishes, and washed her slobber off the windows. I picked up her toys and put her brush away; yet I keep looking for her, expecting to find her peeking around the corner of the hutch or the closet door. I cry every time I see that single dog dish for Zoey next to the counter, and miss my girl every minute of the day. The house is so quiet without her.
Mason keeps calling for her. He had a certain squeal he’d use when he wanted to see her, and she’d come running every time she heard him. This morning, he squealed and peered through the slats in his crib; wondering why she wasn’t coming in to greet him.
And poor Zoey. She’s heartbroken. She mopes around all day, following us from room to room, waiting for Charlie to come through the door. She paces around the yard, as if she’s forgetting to look behind the shed or underneath the deck. Like maybe, if she looks in the right place, Charlie will pop out and greet her with a body slam and a nuzzle.
Right now, it’s hard. I know it will get better. I know it will. But for right now, I feel empty.
I miss my girl.
I’m sorry, Charlie.